Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
[x]

deviantART

 

How to Give Feedback 2 by ~suki-tto-sushi:iconsuki-tto-sushi:





So the viewer (you perhaps?) stumble upon a deviation, the how is unique. What does one do?



About emoticons:
1. NEVER leave only an emoticon as the comment. Artists HATE that! It doesn’t tell the artist whether the art was good or not, whether the art can improve or not. And emoticon is as useful to an artist as nothing at all. Trust me, leaving only an emoticon will get you nothing in return.

2. DO NOT leave ridiculously repeated emoticons unless one knows this person closely. If it was a random deviant then refrain yourself! I mean, with only three times, I get the picture; I’m sure other artists are the same way. With my friends, I allow them to do it because I know it is their expression of happiness, but if a stranger did it, it would just annoy me.



About +fav:
DO NOT, I repeat, DO NOT press the +fav button without a comment! In my case and several of my artist friends’ cases, we would rather have a comment than a +fav! Feedback is like blood! Give blood, give life! Fuel the artist’s inspiration, gusto, and self-worth by leaving words! Don’t be lazy and give the artist just one click of the mouse…



About full view:
ALWAYS FULL VIEW! The joy an artist gets from seeing his or her deviation viewed full view more than normal is overwhelming! It makes an artist feel as though the art is WORTH looking at… WORTH having a second look… WORTH having a closer look… Do artists a favor: FULL VIEW! Especially if the artist specifically asked for it! Usually if the artist tells the viewers to full view, it’s to make the viewers see something not easily seen! And, the art is so much more enjoyable that way! Why fill your screen with DA’s ugly gray when it can be full of vibrant color?
(With help from RandomClaire-chan) If you don't feel like pressing on the deviation twice, try looking at them as a full view from the start! Here's what you do.
Go to Settings ==> Go to Browsing ==> Where it says Open Deviations, change it from Zoomed Out to Zoomed In
Voila! The deviations you open will automatically be in full view!



About artist’s comments / notes:
1. ALWAYS read them! If the viewers don’t, they are risking to make themselves look like dumb asses.
     a. The artist could have mentioned what materials he or she used so when the viewer asks “you must tell me what you used to get this effect!” the artist will think “uhm, dumb ass, look at my comments! I tell you what I used!”
     b. Similarly, if the genre was fanart, the artist could have mentioned what anime/game/etc. it was and what character is being portrayed. If the artist already told his or her viewers, the one viewer that asked “so who is this character and where is he/she/it from?” is looked upon as an idiot.
     c. Lastly, if the viewer wanted to give helpful criticism, then do so! However, if the artist mentioned “I know I used a different style so please do not tell me that the arms are too big or that you liked my previous style better” and the viewer tells the artist “the arms look a little broad. Did you change styles?” then the viewer has marked a big, fat, bold “stupid” on his or her forehead.
Viewers, do yourselves a favor: READ THE ARTISTS’ COMMENTS!



About criticism:
1. CRITICISM IS NOT BAD!!! I cannot stress this enough! Not all criticism is bad! There is such a thing as helpful criticism! Trust me! When you tell an artist “the chin is off” or “the hands are too big” or “the proportion looks like it needs work” the artist will take it as it is or love you for it! And, believe me, it’s usually the latter! I have never met an artist fully confident about his or her art that he or she never looks for something to make the artwork better.

2. DO NOT FLAME!!! Okay, I understand if you prefer one art over another: it’s called preference. But to completely belittle the art and the artist is puerile, immature, rude, hurtful, and, as I mentioned in the first, it is an insult to the flamer’s intelligence! All flamers will be properly dealt with and by this I do not mean we go to the administrators at all times. So make yourself look like an intelligent being: if you don’t like something, just live as though you never saw it. Go on with life.

3. DO NOT leave one word comments. This is almost as irritating as emoticon-only comments! “Cute.” Okay, so the artist knows it’s cute; that was probably the artist’s intention! But WHAT about it was it cute? “Good.” Thank you Sherlock, I’m glad you deducted the art was good, but I have to ask “and…?” We want moooooore! Words give artist life!

4. DO NOT say “this is good but it looks like someone else’s work.” The artist thanks for being observant and hurtful, even if unintentionally. This is ONLY understandable if you compared an artist’s art to a professional artist; and by professional, meaning it is his or her career not a hobby like most fellow deviants. Maybe it was meant to be flattering, but if compared to a fellow deviant, artists will just take it as a sugar-coated plagiarism accusation! So, on second thought, try to avoid comparing for you will never know if he or she enjoys comparison or not.

5. ALWAYS mention a small detail! This is why the one word comments irritate the artists so! The one word is soooo vague! I will give you examples:
Bad: “Awesome (insert emoticon here)”
Good: “I really like the variety of colors you used here! The blending of the colors remind me of the aurora borealis and gives a sense of wonder and somehow nostalgia. This deviation is awesome! (insert emoticon here)”
I mean really now that was, what, three sentences? You’re telling me you can’t write three measly sentences?? For that, I say one thing: hooked on phonics! HOP helps!
Also, artists absolutely love putting in a detail that the viewer would have to search to see! If one viewer notices it and mentions to the artist that he or she has seen it, the artist will be ecstatic. I speak from experience and from first-hand sources.

*~*~*~*~*             *~*~*~*~*             *~*~*~*~*             *~*~*~*~*             *~*~*~*~*

Now to put everything in a nutshell, I will group them into DO NOTs and STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE by importance!

DO NOT:
1. Leave only one emoticon
2. Leave only one word (if you’re going to do either of these, then don’t bother to do anything at all)
3.  Skip the artist’s comments
4. DO NOT FLAME!

STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE!
Step 1: Read the artist’s comments (I switched steps one and two because if the deviation is adult only, then it’s good to be warned first)
Step 2: FULL VIEW!
Step 3: DO NOT do the DO NOTs!
Step 4: Mention something the artist could do to improve! If there’s nothing that could make such perfection better, then tell the artist so! I’m sure he or she will be very flattered!
Step 5: Mention a small detail before saying something broad (see above for example)
Step 6: BE FRIENDLY! Be a friend and we’ll be one back! Just because you worship someone does not mean you can’t be friends! I speak from experience! Nothing worse than being awkward so… just… BE FRIENDLY!
©2004-2009 ~suki-tto-sushi
:iconsuki-tto-sushi:

Author's Comments

THE NEW AND (hopefully) IMPROVED HOW TO GIVE FEEDBACK!

The holidays are more or less over so I decided, “hey, why not? Let’s touch up the how to give feedback!” So I’m hoping this one is more organized, more understandable, and, of course, more helpful! After all, I’m not writing this for my health, I’m writing for you, artists and viewers all!

For those who haven’t ever seen this before, I had three reasons on why this would benefit everyone:
1. Make the artist happier
2. Increase the viewer’s chances of being replied to and
3. Allow the artist to rest assured there ARE competent viewers.

Once again, every single word is by me as well as the picture! So everything is (c) me though I give you permission to tweak anything in here and call it yours. The only thing you can't take is my art. This is to help YOU!

I have put little *~*~* for those that can't stand reading really long essays so those that have the attention span of a rodent like me, scroll to the astrics and read on from there! Though I would read my detailed explanation to avoid confusion, but I can't force anything upon anyone now can I? Especially since this is for YOU.

Fellow viewers, fellow critics, and fellow artists, I love you all! :blowkiss:

had given me the wonderful idea of showing fellow deviants on how to set the settings to full view so I edited it! Check it out! Thank you Claire-chan!

Comments


love 0 0 joy 3 3 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconkagome147:
This is so helpful. :hug: I'm so glad you did. This one is much easier to understand. I hope more people see this! *goes to update signature* =3

--
Clubs ---> [link]

[link] - How to give feedback- By: =suki-tto-sushi
:iconladyoyuki:
Hey........ I have that picture! ^_^ I've had that picie for um....... a long time. Good info on the feedback thing too. I tend to leave feedback in odd ways, but hell, for you - it's always snazzy feedback... 'cause I love you! And if I was going to scold you for icky mistakes (which you have none anyway silly onna) I wouldn't be so stoopid as to post them on DA. Myan. *cuddles you* Oh yeah! I love how liberated and openly opinionated you've become. It's refreshing and sexy too. ^_^ You've much matured. *chu*

Ai,
~Me

--
~I would like to make a toast to bread. Because without bread... there would be no toast.~
[link]
I have a neopet! You should get one too. ^_~ Click on this link, sign up for FREE and love a pet today.
:iconsuki-tto-sushi:
Oh yay! :w00t: I'm glad it's better! It made everything worth it now! :heart: Thanks for your continuous support! :hug: It means so much to me!

--
Cheapest commissions in dA + custom buttons!

My answer to the Davos Question: Give hugs and kisses whenever you can. The world needs more love and today may be your last chance.
:iconkagome147:
I'm glad you're happy. :D You're welcome. I will contiue to do my best to support you. :salute:

--
Clubs ---> [link]

[link] - How to give feedback- By: =suki-tto-sushi
:iconpeaceoflorien:
cute.














JUST kidding. I actually think this is well-written. Maybe a little vicious, a bit menacing, but well-executed none the less. You cannot force people to leave bitterly long stupid thoughtless messages, though. Sometimes people don't have anything helpful to say. I completely agree with you though, I hate giving or getting short annoying comments, but sometimes thats all people have to give. You have to take it for what it is, all people are different. Alas, that's why we have art. =) This was fun reading though.

Jenny
:iconsuki-tto-sushi:
I know I mentioned in there somewhere that I can't force anyone to do anything. As I said, this was completely to help, not to shove something down someone's throat if they don't want it. It's not medicine and it's not poison; something like coke, if you want it, take it, but if you don't want it, leave it. Simple as that. I'm not an instigator, I'm not the DA dministrator out there to dictate, I'm just a regular member just wanting to help.

Thank you for your comment. In three seconds I was braindead to shocked to laughing. I haven't done that before... :3 In any case, I appreciate your words greatly! I take them to heart, even if forcing was never my intention to begin with. You're right. Sometimes short annoying comments are all people have to give, but I wrote this to show them that meaningful comments are possible and easy to compose. If they so asked, I would pick a deviation (or take a deviation of their choice) and show them how I would comment using my guide. I'm not at all bothered to help people however I can.

--
Cheapest commissions in dA + custom buttons!

My answer to the Davos Question: Give hugs and kisses whenever you can. The world needs more love and today may be your last chance.
:iconpetit-ninja:
I enjoy these little feedback essays, because I find it really hard for me to give feedback. ^^; I easily am worried that the artist will take it the wrong way.

I lurk around fanficton.net, I leave one little piece of feedback and the writer get really worked up. But I don't mind a few pieces of feedback here, and there. I mean I know my spelling, and grammar isn't exactly the best, but when I see comments telling me about how it needs improvment i'm glad to know.
I wouldn't want to think "Oh, there is no comments about grammar, I guess I should keep on writing like this!"

But im just rambling now. :D

--
:love: Crazy fangirl of HoroHoro. :licking:

There's a wad of money inside my pocket~
Really... If you tap it the wads of bills will become two~
- Morita :D
:iconwillyoubleed:
:w00t:


XDDDDD


<3

You know I loved it xD
:iconmyles-renoma:
Le-Siiighh... It seems that some people still fail to leave some comments... I now know what it feels like not to bel left comments when someone faves something. Not that I'm going to point fingures... This will help me a lot. Thank you for making it more clear to me. Bye-Bye

--
"There are two types of friends in this world; those who would die to be with you, or those who would rather die than be with you."
~Kirimari

Ich möchte ein Luftkissenfahrzeug mit Käse!
:iconsuki-tto-sushi:
I'm glad you did! :heart: :heart:

--
Cheapest commissions in dA + custom buttons!

My answer to the Davos Question: Give hugs and kisses whenever you can. The world needs more love and today may be your last chance.

Details

December 26, 2004
7.7 KB
16.7 KB
291×183

Statistics

153
20 [who?]
3,350 (0 today)
960 (0 today)

Site Map